She left me because I forgot to put the lid back on the Miracle Whip
Relationships are hard. And sometimes she responds to something I did, but it’s not the real reason – she is angry about something else I did, maybe months ago.
One time a woman left left me because I forgot to put the lid back on the Miracle Whip. I have no idea what the real reason was.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e2e43/e2e4349378e6924f3228bbea2da6b1f25d3b286c" alt=""
Maybe it was the Miracle Whip.